Question 1

Why did Herod order all the children in Bethlehem to be killed?

Accepted Answer

Herod heard from the visiting wise men that a child had been born who was called the king of the Jews. He planned to use them to find the child and secretly get rid of him. When they did not return, and instead went home a different way after God warned them in a dream, Herod felt tricked and became very angry. Fearing that this new king would threaten his rule, he chose a brutal solution. He sent soldiers to kill all the boys two years old and under in Bethlehem and the surrounding area, hoping to remove Jesus among them.

Question 2

What does the slaughter of the infants teach about human evil?

Accepted Answer

This event shows how far a hard and fearful heart can go when it refuses God. Herod was not attacked or harmed by these babies. They had done nothing to him, and their parents had not wronged him. Yet his desire to keep power led him to destroy many innocent lives. The passage reminds us that sin and selfish ambition can grow into shocking cruelty when left unchecked. It also shows that evil often reacts fiercely when God’s purposes move forward, even when God has come into the world as a helpless child.

Question 3

Who are the children in Bethlehem called to mind in this passage?

Accepted Answer

The children are the baby boys in Bethlehem and nearby villages, from two years old and under, whom Herod’s soldiers killed by his command. They are not named, but they are remembered together as victims of his fear and rage. They had no choice in what happened to them. Some readers have seen them as early witnesses to Christ, because they died on account of his birth. Their short lives and deaths draw attention to how the arrival of God’s Son was met with both worship and hatred right from the start.

Question 4

Why is Rachel described as weeping for her children?

Accepted Answer

Rachel was one of Israel’s mothers, the wife of Jacob, buried near the road by Bethlehem. Long after her death, her name was used to picture the sorrow of the families in that area. When the children were taken or killed, it was as if Rachel herself cried out from her grave for her lost sons and daughters. The words about her weeping were first used about an earlier national tragedy, when people were taken away. Matthew applies that same picture of deep, bitter mourning to the mothers of Bethlehem who had just lost their little ones.

Question 5

What is the meaning of the prophecy about a voice heard in Ramah?

Accepted Answer

The prophecy speaks of a voice in Ramah, full of lamentation, weeping, and great mourning, with Rachel crying for her children and refusing comfort because they are gone. In its first setting, this described the pain when families from that region were taken away or destroyed. By quoting it here, the passage shows that the same kind of grief returns when Herod’s soldiers kill the children around Bethlehem. It connects an old sorrow with this new tragedy, while hinting that, as before, God has not forgotten his people and will still bring restoration.

Question 6

How is Jeremiah’s picture of Rachel weeping fulfilled here?

Accepted Answer

The earlier words about Rachel weeping fit this event because her tomb was near Bethlehem, and families in that area again faced terrible loss. When Herod’s soldiers killed the young boys, many mothers cried out with the same kind of grief described before. Matthew says this is a fulfillment, not because the first sorrow did not really happen, but because the same pattern appears again around the birth of Christ. The old picture of a grieving mother now applies freshly to these new tears, showing that God saw both tragedies and had spoken about this kind of sorrow long before.

Question 7

What does this passage show about God’s control and human suffering?

Accepted Answer

The passage holds two truths together. First, Herod is fully responsible for his cruel choice. He plans the killing, sends out the soldiers, and acts without justice or mercy. Second, the passage says that what happened fulfilled words God had already spoken. That does not make the evil good, but it shows that even the darkest acts cannot stop God’s plan. God protected Jesus, who had already been taken to safety, and would still bring salvation through him. The suffering is real and terrible, yet it does not overturn what God intends to do through his Son.

Question 8

Why would God allow these infants to die when Jesus was rescued?

Accepted Answer

The passage does not answer every question we might have, but it does give some help. Jesus is saved because his mission is to bring rescue to many, so his life is preserved. The infants who die suffer because of another’s sin, which is part of the brokenness of this world. Some readers have seen their deaths as a kind of early witness, since they die on account of Christ’s coming. We are meant to feel the weight of this sorrow, yet also see that God is still working a greater salvation that will one day deal with all injustice and tears.

Question 9

How can this painful story give any comfort or hope today?

Accepted Answer

This story is hard to read, especially for anyone who has lost a child or seen terrible injustice. One way it gives comfort is by showing that the Bible does not hide or soften human cruelty. It faces it honestly. It also shows that God came into a world like this, where rulers kill to keep power, and where innocent people suffer. The same chapter that speaks of Rachel’s weeping also speaks of future hope and restoration. In the same way, the birth of Jesus in the middle of such grief points to a Savior who knows our pain and will, in time, wipe away every tear.

Question 10

Why does this passage seem so difficult to understand emotionally?

Accepted Answer

This passage is difficult because it joins the joy of Jesus’ birth with the horror of children being killed. Our hearts naturally ask why such a thing would be allowed. The Bible does not explain everything, but it does show that God is honest about the worst things people do. It shows that even when evil seems to win, God’s plan is still moving forward, and his Son has entered this kind of world, not a safe one. Sitting with this story can deepen our sense of how serious sin is and how much we need the hope that Christ brings.

Matthew 2:16

Then Herod, when he saw that he was mocked of the wise men, was exceeding wroth, and sent forth, and slew all the children that were in Bethlehem, and in all the coasts thereof, from two years old and under, according to the time which he had diligently enquired of the wise men.

Weeping and Great Mourning

Cross References

Matthew 2:16

Then Herod, when he saw that he was mocked of the wise men, was exceeding wroth, and sent forth, and slew all the children that were in Bethlehem, and in all the coasts thereof, from two years old and under, according to the time which he had diligently enquired of the wise men.

Share Options

All Verses

Verse + Context

Current Verse

Weeping and Great Mourning

Cross References