Question 1

What does it mean to "err from the truth" in this passage?

Accepted Answer

To “err from the truth” means a believer has turned aside from what is true about Christ and the gospel, or from a life that fits that truth. It can be drifting in wrong teaching, or slipping into sinful ways after once walking in obedience. James is not mainly talking about someone who never knew Christ, but about one who has been in the church, confessed the faith, and then wandered in belief, behavior, or both. It is a serious spiritual danger, not just a small mistake.

Question 2

Who is the "sinner" that is converted in this verse?

Accepted Answer

The “sinner” here is best understood as a wandering believer, a brother or sister who has strayed from the truth they once followed. James has been speaking to “brethren,” so the focus is on someone inside the Christian community, not just any person in the world. This sinner may have fallen into false teaching, open sin, or coldness toward God. Calling them a sinner shows how serious their condition is, even though they still belong to the people of God.

Question 3

What does it mean to "convert" or turn someone back in this context?

Accepted Answer

To “convert” or turn someone back here is not talking about their very first coming to faith, but about restoring them after they have fallen away in some way. A fellow believer becomes an instrument God uses to bring the wanderer back to the truth. This can happen through gentle correction, clear teaching, honest warning, loving rebuke, and especially prayer. God alone truly saves, but he uses the care and words of his people as tools to turn someone from a dangerous path.

Question 4

How does converting a sinner "save a soul from death"?

Accepted Answer

Saving a soul from death means rescuing someone from the path that leads to final separation from God. A believer who keeps wandering in serious error or sin is heading toward ruin. When another Christian helps that person turn back, God uses that act to pull them back from the edge. The helper is not the savior, but an instrument God uses. James wants us to feel the weight of this: helping a wandering brother or sister return is not small, it is about eternal life and death.

Question 5

What does it mean to "hide a multitude of sins" in this verse?

Accepted Answer

“Hide a multitude of sins” points to sins being covered and no longer held against the person. This hiding is not about pretending sin is not there, but about God forgiving and blotting it out. When a sinner is turned back and truly repents, many sins are dealt with at once. They are covered by what Christ has done, so they are no longer exposed before God’s judgment. James shows how great it is to help someone return, because through their turning, many sins are forgiven and put away.

Question 6

Why is this passage important for how Christians relate to each other?

Accepted Answer

This passage shows that believers are not meant to live the Christian life alone. James speaks to “brethren” and gives them a shared duty to watch over each other. When someone wanders, others should not ignore it, gossip about it, or give up on them. Instead, they should lovingly seek their restoration. God chooses to work through this kind of care. So Christians are called to be honest, patient, and persistent with each other, knowing God can use them to protect a soul from great harm.

Question 7

How does this teaching connect with James’s words about prayer and confession?

Accepted Answer

Just before these verses, James talks about praying in suffering, calling the elders for the sick, and confessing sins to one another. Then he speaks of converting a sinner from the error of his way. The flow shows that prayer, confession, and restoration all belong together. The same God who hears the prayer of faith for healing also uses prayer and loving correction to heal hearts and minds. Caring for the spiritually sick is as important as caring for the physically sick.

Question 8

How can I apply this passage when I see someone drifting from the faith?

Accepted Answer

When you see someone drifting, this passage invites you not to sit back. Start with prayer, asking God to work in their heart and to give you wisdom and love. Then, if you have opportunity, gently talk with them. Point them back to the truth about Christ and to a life that fits that truth. Be patient and humble, aware of your own weakness. The goal is not to win an argument but to help a brother or sister be restored. God may use your quiet faithfulness to guard their soul.

Question 9

Why does this verse seem difficult about whose soul and whose sins are saved or hidden?

Accepted Answer

The wording here has been read in more than one way. Some understand “save a soul” and “hide a multitude of sins” as mainly about the wandering person, whose soul is rescued and whose many sins are forgiven. Others see a hint that the one who helps also benefits, since such love reflects a forgiven heart. What is clear either way is that God values the work of restoring someone who has strayed, and that through this turning back, many sins are mercifully dealt with and not left exposed.

James 5:19

Brethren, if any of you do err from the truth, and one convert him;

Restoring a Sinner

Cross References

James 5:19

Brethren, if any of you do err from the truth, and one convert him;

Share Options

All Verses

Verse + Context

Current Verse

Restoring a Sinner

Cross References