Question 1

What does "though your sins be as scarlet" mean in this passage?

Accepted Answer

The picture of sins being “as scarlet” and “red like crimson” points to very deep, obvious guilt. Scarlet and crimson were strong dyes that sank into the fabric and did not easily fade. In the same way, the people’s sins were many, serious, and well known before God. Their hands were full of blood, and their hearts were stained. Yet God says that, if they turn back to Him, He will make them “white as snow” and “as wool.” This means He is willing to fully forgive and treat them as clean in His sight.

Question 2

What does it mean when God says "Come now, and let us reason together"?

Accepted Answer

When God says, “Come now, and let us reason together,” He is inviting His people to come near and think the matter through with Him. They had complained in their hearts that His ways were too hard, but God shows that His terms are fair. If they turn from evil and obey, He will forgive and bless them. If they keep rebelling, they will face ruin. He is not asking them to argue with His justice at a court of law, but to listen at the place of mercy and see that what He asks is right and good.

Question 3

What is promised to those who are "willing and obedient" in this passage?

Accepted Answer

The promise to those who are “willing and obedient” is that they “shall eat the good of the land.” For the people first hearing this, that meant enjoying the good things of the land God had given them, living in peace with its food and blessings. It points to a life where God’s favor rests on them, not because they are perfect, but because they have turned from stubborn disobedience and now gladly submit to His ways. With sins pardoned, even ordinary blessings become sweet and can be enjoyed with a clear conscience.

Question 4

What does "if ye refuse and rebel, ye shall be devoured with the sword" mean?

Accepted Answer

“If ye refuse and rebel, ye shall be devoured with the sword” is a plain warning. If the people harden themselves, keep resisting God’s rule, and reject His mercy, they will be destroyed by war. The “sword” points to enemy armies God would send against them, and also to His own righteous anger. They could not expect to despise His offers of grace and still be safe. This shows that God’s patience does not cancel justice. Those who will not be led by His gentle rule will finally be broken by His judgment.

Question 5

How does this passage show both God’s mercy and God’s justice?

Accepted Answer

This passage holds mercy and justice side by side. On one hand, God invites guilty people to come and talk with Him. He promises that even sins as dark as scarlet can become white, meaning He is ready to forgive fully. On the other hand, He clearly says that if they refuse and keep rebelling, they will be devoured by the sword. There is a real choice set before them: forgiveness and blessing with repentance and obedience, or ruin with stubborn disobedience. God is gentle in His invitation but firm in His warning.

Question 6

Who is God speaking to when He offers to make sins "white as snow"?

Accepted Answer

God is speaking to the people of Judah, who were outwardly very religious but were living in violence, injustice, and hypocrisy. Some among them were deeply troubled by their sin and afraid there was no hope. To such people, God holds out this promise that their scarlet sins can become white as snow and as wool. He is addressing real sinners, not people who think they are almost good enough already. This shows that His promise of cleansing is meant for those who see their guilt and are willing to return to Him.

Question 7

What was happening among the people when God gave this call to reason together?

Accepted Answer

At that time the people were bringing many sacrifices and religious offerings, but their lives were full of evil. They were shedding innocent blood and neglecting justice for the weak, like orphans and widows. God had just told them that He was tired of their empty worship and would not listen to their prayers while they clung to sin. Into that situation He calls them to wash, make themselves clean, learn to do good, and then says, “Come now, and let us reason together,” laying out the path of mercy or judgment before them.

Question 8

How can this passage about scarlet sins becoming white as snow apply today?

Accepted Answer

This passage speaks to anyone who feels stained by sin and wonders if God could ever forgive them. It shows that God does not only forgive small or hidden faults, but even sins that seem like a deep, fixed stain. He calls people to stop doing evil, learn to do good, and come to Him in humble repentance. When they do, He does not meet them with coldness but with cleansing and welcome. It also warns that if we harden our hearts and keep refusing His call, we cannot expect peace, but only the fruit of our own rebellion.

Question 9

Why does God tie blessing in the land to being "willing and obedient"?

Accepted Answer

God connects enjoying the “good of the land” with being “willing and obedient” to show that His outward gifts are linked with how His people respond to Him. It is not that their obedience earns His love, but that stubborn disobedience robs them of the blessings He is ready to give. When they gladly submit to His ways, He allows them to stay in the land and enjoy its good things. When they refuse, the same land becomes a place of war and loss. This teaches that God’s commands are given for their good, not to harm them.

Question 10

Why might some people find the warning in this passage hard to accept?

Accepted Answer

Some people feel that talk of judgment and being devoured by the sword sounds too severe. They might think their sins are not serious enough to deserve such an end, or that a loving God would not punish. The passage answers this by setting the whole matter out clearly. God offers real forgiveness and blessing if they turn, and only threatens destruction if they insist on refusing and rebelling. The warning is hard to hear, but it is not unfair. It shows that ongoing resistance to God’s kindness leads to a path that ends in ruin.

Isaiah 1:18

Come now, and let us reason together, saith the Lord: though your sins be as scarlet, they shall be as white as snow; though they be red like crimson, they shall be as wool.

Meaningless Offerings

“Let Us Reason”

Cross References

Isaiah 1:18

Come now, and let us reason together, saith the Lord: though your sins be as scarlet, they shall be as white as snow; though they be red like crimson, they shall be as wool.

Share Options

All Verses

Verse + Context

Current Verse

Meaningless Offerings

“Let Us Reason”

Cross References