Question 1

What does “cast thy bread upon the waters” mean?

Accepted Answer

“Cast thy bread upon the waters” is a picture of generous giving. Bread points to what you live on, your basic goods and money. Throwing it on the water looks like loss, as if you will never see it again. Here it means sharing freely with others, especially the needy, even when you cannot see how it will come back. The promise “thou shalt find it after many days” teaches that God does not forget such kindness. The return may be delayed and may not look the way you expect, but it is not wasted.

Question 2

Why are we told to give a portion to seven and also to eight?

Accepted Answer

“Give a portion to seven, and also to eight” means be generous to many people, not just one or two. Seven and eight picture a wide, overflowing sharing of what you have. The teacher ties this to the fact that we do not know what trouble may come on the earth. Since life is uncertain, we should not cling tightly to our goods, but spread help while we can. By giving to several, you do not put all your mercy in one place, and you show a heart that reflects God’s open hand.

Question 3

What does it mean that he who observes the wind shall not sow?

Accepted Answer

“He that observeth the wind shall not sow” speaks of a person who keeps waiting for perfect conditions and so never acts. A farmer who stares at the wind and clouds, afraid of every risk, will never sow or reap. In the passage this warns against letting fear, excuses, or overthinking stop you from doing good, working, or giving. Since we cannot control or predict everything, the wise way is to move ahead in faith and duty, using the chances God gives instead of waiting for a day with no problems.

Question 4

What does this passage teach about God’s hidden work?

Accepted Answer

The teacher says we do not know the way of the spirit or how bones grow in the womb, and in the same way we do not know the works of God who makes all. This reminds us that many parts of life are beyond our understanding. God is at work in secret ways in creation, in our lives, and in the results of our actions. Because of this, we should not demand to see all outcomes before we act. Instead, we trust God’s wisdom, do our duty, give, work, and leave the results in his hands.

Question 5

Why does the teacher urge sowing in the morning and evening?

Accepted Answer

“In the morning sow thy seed, and in the evening withhold not thine hand” means keep on doing good and working diligently through all of life. Morning and evening picture different times and seasons. Since you do not know which effort will prosper, or whether both will be good, you should not stop after one try or one season. This applies to work, acts of kindness, and service. Rather than guessing which deed will count most, keep going in simple faith, knowing God can bless any or all of it.

Question 6

How can we rejoice in life yet remember the days of darkness?

Accepted Answer

The teacher says light is sweet and it is pleasant to see the sun, and that a person may rejoice in many years. At the same time, he tells us to remember the days of darkness, for they will be many, and that all that comes is vanity. This balance keeps us from clinging to this world. We can enjoy God’s daily gifts with a thankful heart, but we should remember that sickness, old age, and death are coming. Joy is right, yet it should be humble, knowing how quickly life passes.

Question 7

What does “rejoice O young man in thy youth” mean with judgment coming?

Accepted Answer

The call to “rejoice, O young man, in thy youth” is not permission to sin freely. It invites the young to enjoy the strength and cheer of youth, to walk in ways that please their hearts and eyes, but with this warning: God will bring all into judgment. So the joy of youth should be kept within God’s will. The passage is gently ironic toward those who chase pleasure as if there were no account to give. Real joy is found when youth is spent in ways that will stand in God’s court.

Question 8

Why does the passage say childhood and youth are vanity?

Accepted Answer

When it says “childhood and youth are vanity,” it is not saying these years have no value. Vanity here speaks of how brief and passing they are. Youth is full of strength and desire, but it slips away quickly. Because of this, the teacher urges young people to put away inner sorrow like anger and envy, and to turn from bodily sins. In other words, do not waste your short springtime on empty paths. Use it well, in joy and in obedience, knowing it will soon be gone.

Question 9

How should this teaching on generosity and judgment shape my life today?

Accepted Answer

This passage invites you to hold your possessions loosely and your days seriously. Since you do not know what tomorrow will bring, you can choose to give now, to work faithfully, and not to wait for perfect conditions. At the same time, you can enjoy God’s good gifts, especially while you are young, yet remember that every choice will be weighed by God. Let this move you to quiet courage: be open-handed with others, steady in your tasks, and watchful over your heart and body, aiming to please God.

Ecclesiastes 11:1

Cast thy bread upon the waters: for thou shalt find it after many days.

Cast Your Bread upon the Waters

Enjoy Your Years

Cast Your Bread upon the Waters

Cross References

Ecclesiastes 11:1

Cast thy bread upon the waters: for thou shalt find it after many days.

Share Options

All Verses

Verse + Context

Current Verse

Cast Your Bread upon the Waters

Enjoy Your Years

Cast Your Bread upon the Waters

Cross References