Question 1

Why did David say, "As the Lord liveth, who hath redeemed my soul out of all adversity"?

Accepted Answer

David’s words are like an oath. He is saying that the living God has been the one who rescued him again and again from trouble, especially from Saul’s long pursuit and from those who opposed him afterward. By speaking this way, David shows he trusts God to bring him to the throne in the right way. He does not need sneaky or violent acts from others to help him. This sets the stage for why he rejects the “help” of men who think murder will please him.

Question 2

Why did David mention the man who brought news that Saul was dead?

Accepted Answer

David brings up the earlier man to show a pattern. That man thought David would be glad to hear that Saul had died and expected a reward. Instead, David had him put to death, because he treated Saul’s death like something to profit from. Now David says, if he punished someone who only claimed to bring news of a death, how much more should he punish men who actually killed their master and brought the head as if it were a gift. This explains why their plan badly misread David’s heart.

Question 3

Why does David call Ish-bosheth a "righteous person"?

Accepted Answer

David calls Ish-bosheth righteous in contrast to the wicked men who killed him. Ish-bosheth had not wronged them, and whatever stand he took against David came more from confusion and the influence of others than from personal hatred. David chooses to think the best of him. He recognizes that Ish-bosheth did not deserve to die this way, in his own house and on his bed. By using this word, David shows respect for Saul’s house and refuses to excuse murder by political reasons.

Question 4

What was so evil about killing Ish-bosheth in his own house upon his bed?

Accepted Answer

Killing Ish-bosheth in his house and on his bed made the act especially dark. A home should be a place of safety, and a bed is where someone is most defenseless. Ish-bosheth was not in battle or attacking anyone. He was at rest, with no chance to defend himself. This turns the act into treachery and cowardice, not bravery. David points this out to show how far from honorable their deed was, and why it must be answered with judgment rather than reward.

Question 5

Why did David have Rechab and Baanah killed and their hands and feet cut off?

Accepted Answer

David orders their death as an act of justice. As king, he acts like the avenger of blood, requiring the life of those who shed innocent blood. Their hands and feet are cut off because these were the parts used to carry out and rush to the murder. Their mutilated bodies are then hung up in a public place by the pool in Hebron. This shames the killers and warns everyone that David will not gain or keep his kingdom through secret murder or betrayal, and that such acts will be punished.

Question 6

Why were Rechab and Baanah hanged over the pool in Hebron?

Accepted Answer

They were displayed over the pool in Hebron because it was a public area where many people would see them. This was meant as a clear warning. Their bodies, or at least their hands and feet, showed the people what happens to those who commit such wicked murders and expect praise for it. It also showed that David’s rule would not be built on treachery. Instead of hiding the case, David allowed their punishment to be seen so people would fear doing the same kind of thing.

Question 7

Why was Ish-bosheth’s head buried in the sepulchre of Abner in Hebron?

Accepted Answer

Ish-bosheth’s head was buried in Abner’s tomb in Hebron to give him a respectful resting place. Abner had been a leading man from Saul’s house, and David had already honored him in death. By joining Ish-bosheth’s remains to Abner’s grave, David shows public respect for Saul’s family and separates himself from the crime. This act helps make it clear that David does not rejoice in the fall of Saul’s line, but wants justice and proper honor, even for those who once stood in his way.

Question 8

What does this passage show about David’s character as a leader?

Accepted Answer

This passage shows David as a leader who hates secret killing and refuses to use sin to reach his goals. He trusts God to raise him up and will not reward people who think they can win his favor by murder. He is willing to act firmly as a judge, but he also honors the dead from Saul’s house. His justice is not driven by revenge, but by a desire to uphold what is right in public. This helps the people see that his kingdom is not built on cruelty or treachery.

Question 9

How does David’s response warn against using evil means for a good end?

Accepted Answer

Rechab and Baanah seem to think that killing Ish-bosheth will help David’s rule and that this will excuse their crime. David’s reaction shows the opposite. He will not accept evil acts, even if they appear to help God’s plan or his kingdom. Instead of rewarding them, he judges them. This warns anyone who might think they can serve God or “help” his chosen king by lying, violence, or treachery. God’s work is not to be carried forward by sin, and those who try that path face shame and judgment.

Question 10

What does this passage teach about trusting God in times of danger or opposition?

Accepted Answer

David’s words about the Lord redeeming his soul from all adversity show where his confidence lies. He looks back and sees how God has brought him through many dangers, including Saul’s attacks and conflict with Saul’s house. Because of this, he refuses to lean on wicked schemes or accept help from violent men. For readers, this shows that trust in God means waiting for him to work in his way and time, rather than grabbing at sinful shortcuts when life is hard or when we feel threatened.

2 Samuel 4:9

¶ And David answered Rechab and Baanah his brother, the sons of Rimmon the Beerothite, and said unto them, As the Lord liveth, who hath redeemed my soul out of all adversity,

The Execution of Rechab and Baanah

metadata.crossReferences

2 Samuel 4:9

¶ And David answered Rechab and Baanah his brother, the sons of Rimmon the Beerothite, and said unto them, As the Lord liveth, who hath redeemed my soul out of all adversity,

share.title

share.allVerses

share.verseWithContext

share.currentVerse

The Execution of Rechab and Baanah

metadata.crossReferences