Question 1

What does it mean that David’s heart smote him after numbering the people?

Accepted Answer

The phrase “David’s heart smote him” means his conscience suddenly hit him hard. For many months he went ahead with the census, but afterward he felt deep inner pain and regret. He realized his motives had been proud and foolish, trusting in numbers and strength instead of trusting in God. This inner conviction led him to confess, “I have sinned greatly” and to ask God to take away his iniquity. It shows how God can wake up a sleeping conscience and move a person to honest repentance.

Question 2

Why was taking the census considered a great sin for David?

Accepted Answer

The passage shows that the sin was not the counting itself, but David’s heart behind it. He acted in pride and self-confidence, wanting to measure his strength and people, instead of depending on God. He did not seek God’s will before doing it. The census also seems to have ignored God’s commands about how such counting should be done. So David later sees that he has acted very foolishly, trusting in human numbers and plans instead of honoring God as the true protector of Israel.

Question 3

What are the three punishments God offers David through Gad?

Accepted Answer

God, speaking through the prophet Gad, sets three choices before David. First, several years of famine in the land. Second, a period of running from his enemies while they chase him. Third, three days of pestilence, a deadly plague sent by God through the land. Each choice would bring real suffering on the nation. By giving David these options, God shows both judgment against sin and mercy in allowing David to choose how that judgment will fall.

Question 4

Why does David say, “Let us fall now into the hand of the LORD”?

Accepted Answer

When David hears the three options, he feels trapped because each one is terrible. He says, “I am in a great strait,” meaning he feels pressed on every side. Yet he chooses to fall into the hand of the Lord, especially in the form of the pestilence, because he trusts God’s character. He knows that God’s mercies are great, even when God punishes sin. David would rather be dealt with directly by God than be at the mercy of enemies or depend on other nations for help in a long famine.

Question 5

What does this passage teach about God’s judgment and mercy together?

Accepted Answer

This passage holds judgment and mercy side by side. God does not ignore David’s sin, and a serious punishment must come. The choices given to David show that sin has real and painful consequences, not only for the sinner but for others as well. At the same time, God allows only one judgment, gives David a say in which one, and David counts on God’s great mercy. Even when God disciplines, he remains compassionate and can shorten or soften the judgment according to his grace.

Question 6

Who is Gad in this passage and what is his role?

Accepted Answer

Gad is called David’s seer, meaning a prophet who receives God’s word and guidance for the king. In this story, God sends Gad to David after the census is completed and David has already felt deep conviction. Gad does not come with his own ideas, but with a message from God. He lays out the three possible judgments and waits for David’s answer so he can report it back to God. Gad’s role shows how God uses his messengers to reveal his will and to confront sin.

Question 7

Why is this passage hard to read, with so much suffering mentioned?

Accepted Answer

This passage can feel heavy because one man’s sin leads to suffering across the nation in the verses that follow. It reminds us that sin is not a small thing and often harms others. The wording about choices of famine, war, or pestilence can be disturbing. Faithful readers have sometimes found this difficult, but the passage also pushes us to see both God’s holiness and his mercy. Even in hard judgment, David still throws himself on God’s compassion, showing there is hope for those who turn back to God.

Question 8

How can this story about David’s sin and choice of judgment apply to my life?

Accepted Answer

This story encourages you to take your own sin seriously and not to excuse it. Like David, you may only see the pride or self-reliance in your choices after the fact, when your conscience is stirred. When that happens, this passage shows a way forward: honest confession, asking God to take away your iniquity, and trusting his mercy even if there are consequences. It also warns against putting your confidence in numbers, strength, or plans, instead of depending humbly on God.

2 Samuel 24:10

¶ And David’s heart smote him after that he had numbered the people. And David said unto the Lord, I have sinned greatly in that I have done: and now, I beseech thee, O Lord, take away the iniquity of thy servant; for I have done very foolishly.

Judgment for David’s Sin

metadata.crossReferences

2 Samuel 24:10

¶ And David’s heart smote him after that he had numbered the people. And David said unto the Lord, I have sinned greatly in that I have done: and now, I beseech thee, O Lord, take away the iniquity of thy servant; for I have done very foolishly.

share.title

share.allVerses

share.verseWithContext

share.currentVerse

Judgment for David’s Sin

metadata.crossReferences