Question 1

What was happening between Abner and Joab at the pool of Gibeon?

Accepted Answer

Abner led the servants of Ish-bosheth, Saul’s son, from Mahanaim to Gibeon, while Joab led the servants of David. They met by the pool of Gibeon and sat on opposite sides, facing each other. Abner suggested that young men from each side should rise and “play,” which was really a call to armed contest, not a game. Twelve from each side fought and all fell together, and this sparked a very hard battle. The scene shows rising tension in a divided nation and how pride can turn a standoff into bloodshed.

Question 2

What is the meaning of the young men arising to play before Abner and Joab?

Accepted Answer

When Abner said, “Let the young men now arise, and play before us,” he was not talking about a harmless game. He was calling for a kind of combat display, a duel meant to show skill and courage. Joab agreed, and twelve from each side stepped forward. Each man grabbed his opponent by the head and thrust his sword into his side, so all of them died together. The word “play” shows how lightly they spoke about something deadly, reminding us how people can treat violence as sport and forget the real cost.

Question 3

Who was Asahel, and why did he keep chasing Abner?

Accepted Answer

Asahel was one of the three sons of Zeruiah, David’s sister, and brother to Joab and Abishai. The passage says he was as swift on his feet as a wild deer. In the battle, he fixed his attention on Abner and chased him without turning to the right or left. Abner warned him more than once to turn aside and fight someone else, even offering that he could take another man’s armor. But Asahel refused to turn aside, likely driven by zeal and desire for honor, and his stubborn pursuit ended in his death.

Question 4

Why did Abner warn Asahel before killing him?

Accepted Answer

Abner looked back, recognized Asahel, and twice urged him to stop chasing him. He told Asahel to turn aside and fight one of the young men instead, and asked, “Wherefore should I smite thee to the ground? how then should I hold up my face to Joab thy brother?” Abner knew Asahel was Joab’s brother and did not want to be guilty of killing him. His warnings show he did not seek Asahel’s blood, but Asahel would not turn aside. In the end Abner struck him with the back end of his spear, and Asahel died on the spot.

Question 5

What happened when Abner killed Asahel under the fifth rib?

Accepted Answer

When Asahel refused to stop, Abner struck him with the hinder end of his spear under the fifth rib, and the spear went out behind him. Asahel fell down and died in that same place. The passage notes that everyone who came to the place where he fell stood still, showing how shocking and sobering his death was. Later, Joab and Abishai continued to pursue Abner until sunset. Asahel’s death becomes a turning point, deepening the bitterness between the two sides and showing the sad end of reckless pursuit and pride in battle.

Question 6

What does Abner mean by asking, Shall the sword devour for ever?

Accepted Answer

After the fighting and Asahel’s death, Abner and his men gathered on a hill, and Abner called out to Joab, “Shall the sword devour for ever? knowest thou not that it will be bitterness in the latter end?” He was asking how long they would keep killing each other, warning that the end of such fighting would be only bitterness. Though he had helped start the conflict, he now appealed for it to stop, calling the Israelites “brethren.” His words show a late awareness that civil war among brothers brings lasting sorrow and loss.

Question 7

Why did Joab stop the battle after Abner’s appeal?

Accepted Answer

When Abner called out and urged that the sword should not devour forever, Joab answered that if Abner had not spoken at the start, the people would have gone away in the morning instead of fighting. Joab still ordered a stop. He blew the trumpet, the people stood still, and they no longer pursued Israel or fought. Joab’s reply carries some bitterness, but he accepted that more bloodshed between brothers was pointless. This shows that even hardened leaders can see the waste of ongoing conflict and choose to pull back from it.

Question 8

What does this passage teach about pride, ambition, and the cost of conflict?

Accepted Answer

The story shows how pride and ambition can drag many people into needless suffering. Abner backs Ish-bosheth’s claim and pushes for a show of strength, calling for the young men to “play.” Joab agrees, and a contest that might have been avoided turns into a heavy battle. Asahel’s eagerness and refusal to turn aside end in his death. By the end, Abner speaks of bitterness, and Joab calls the people back. The losses on both sides remind us that chasing honor, control, or revenge can lead to grief, and that it is better to seek peace early.

Question 9

How can this story about Abner, Joab, and Asahel apply to conflicts today?

Accepted Answer

This passage shows how easily tension can grow into open fighting. A proud challenge, a stubborn pursuit, or a sharp word can draw many others into harm. Abner’s late plea and Joab’s decision to sound the trumpet show that someone has to decide, “Enough,” and step back from the fight. Today, this can nudge us to check our own hearts in disagreements, to avoid turning conflict into a contest for honor, and to remember that the people on the other side may be our “brethren.” Seeking peace early often prevents lasting bitterness.

2 Samuel 2:12

¶ And Abner the son of Ner, and the servants of Ish-bosheth the son of Saul, went out from Mahanaim to Gibeon.

The Battle of Gibeon

metadata.crossReferences

2 Samuel 2:12

¶ And Abner the son of Ner, and the servants of Ish-bosheth the son of Saul, went out from Mahanaim to Gibeon.

share.title

share.allVerses

share.verseWithContext

share.currentVerse

The Battle of Gibeon

metadata.crossReferences