Question 1

What is David doing in this passage when he speaks about Saul and Jonathan?

Accepted Answer

In this passage David is singing a lament, a kind of funeral song, for Saul and Jonathan after they have died in battle. He is not gloating over the fall of a rival. Instead, he mourns them with deep sorrow. He calls them the “beauty of Israel” and speaks of how the mighty have fallen. David wants the people to remember their courage and leadership, and he even commands that this song be taught so Judah will not forget their sacrifice.

Question 2

What does the phrase "How are the mighty fallen" mean here?

Accepted Answer

The phrase “How are the mighty fallen” is David’s way of expressing shock and sorrow that strong, honored leaders like Saul and Jonathan have been killed. It is not just about their physical strength, but about their role as Israel’s defenders. By repeating this line, David reminds the people that those they trusted in battle are now gone, and the whole nation feels the loss. It is a cry of grief over the cost of war and the sudden end of human greatness.

Question 3

Why does David say, "Tell it not in Gath" and mention Askelon?

Accepted Answer

Gath and Askelon were Philistine cities. When David says, “Tell it not in Gath” and not to publish it in Askelon, he is longing that Israel’s enemies would not hear about Saul and Jonathan’s deaths and celebrate. He does not want the “daughters of the Philistines” to rejoice over Israel’s shame. This shows how much he cares about God’s honor and the dignity of God’s people, even in a time of deep personal and national grief.

Question 4

Why does David curse the mountains of Gilboa in his lament?

Accepted Answer

David speaks a poetic curse over the mountains of Gilboa, asking that there be no dew or rain there because that is where Saul’s shield was cast away and where he fell. This is not so much a detailed teaching about the land as it is a picture of grief. David feels that the place where Israel’s king died should be marked by sorrow, not fruitfulness. His words show how closely the land, the battle, and the people’s pain are tied together in his mind.

Question 5

How does David describe his friendship with Jonathan in this passage?

Accepted Answer

David speaks of Jonathan with very tender words. He calls him “my brother Jonathan” and says he is deeply distressed over his death. David says Jonathan’s love for him was wonderful, even greater than the love of women, meaning their bond was unusually strong, loyal, and selfless. Jonathan had risked his own future as heir to the throne to stand with David. This lament remembers that deep friendship as one of the richest gifts in David’s life.

Question 6

Why does David praise Saul, even though Saul had opposed him?

Accepted Answer

In this song David chooses to remember Saul’s better side. He speaks of Saul’s strength in battle, his swiftness and courage, and how he blessed the daughters of Israel with fine clothing and ornaments. David also recalls that Saul was anointed as king. By doing this, David shows respect for the office God gave Saul and sets an example of charity in how we speak about people after they die, focusing on what was honorable rather than only on their failures.

Question 7

What is the meaning of "the weapons of war perished" at the end of the lament?

Accepted Answer

When David says, “the weapons of war perished,” he is talking about more than swords and bows. He is speaking about Saul and Jonathan themselves, who had been Israel’s strong defenders. Their deaths mean that the people have lost their main human protectors. The phrase captures the emptiness that follows a great defeat. Human strength and skill in battle have come to an end, and Israel has to face its weakness and loss before God.

Question 8

What does this passage teach about mourning and remembering the dead?

Accepted Answer

This passage shows that it is right to grieve openly and honestly. David does not hide his pain. He writes a song, teaches it to others, and invites the whole nation to weep, especially the daughters of Israel who had benefited from Saul’s rule. At the same time, he honors those who died by remembering their courage and kindness. This teaches us to face loss with both truth and respect, sharing sorrow together and speaking well of those who have gone.

2 Samuel 1:17

¶ And David lamented with this lamentation over Saul and over Jonathan his son:

David’s Song for Saul and Jonathan

metadata.crossReferences

2 Samuel 1:17

¶ And David lamented with this lamentation over Saul and over Jonathan his son:

share.title

share.allVerses

share.verseWithContext

share.currentVerse

David’s Song for Saul and Jonathan

metadata.crossReferences