Question 1

What does “rebuke not an elder” mean in this passage?

Accepted Answer

“Rebuke not an elder” does not mean that older people can never be corrected. It means they should not be corrected in a harsh, attacking way. The word has the sense of hitting with words. When an older man is in error, Timothy is told to speak to him gently, like a respectful son talking to his father. The goal is to persuade, not to crush. It still allows for firm correction when needed, but without rough, disrespectful speech.

Question 2

Who is the “elder” in this verse, an older man or a church leader?

Accepted Answer

In this verse, “elder” mainly points to age, not to a church office. Paul is talking about how Timothy should speak to different groups by age and gender: older men, younger men, older women, and younger women. Elsewhere he speaks about church leaders in a more specific way. Here the focus is on how to correct people in the church family, taking into account their age and treating older men with the same respect you would show a father.

Question 3

How should younger men be treated “as brethren”?

Accepted Answer

Treating younger men “as brethren” means seeing them as brothers in God’s family. Timothy, who was also a younger man, could speak more directly to them, but still with care and love. The aim is not to hunt for faults but to help them turn from wrong. Correction should be honest yet kind, the way you would talk to a brother you care about. There should be no pride or harshness, but a desire to restore and encourage.

Question 4

What does it mean to treat elder women as mothers in this verse?

Accepted Answer

Treating elder women as mothers means correcting them with deep respect, care, and gentleness. If an older woman is in the wrong, Timothy is told not to speak down to her but to reason with her as a child would with a mother. She is to be seen as a “mother in Israel,” someone to honor. This shapes tone and attitude: no rough words, no contempt, but a tender effort to guide her back to what is right.

Question 5

What does “the younger as sisters, with all purity” teach about purity?

Accepted Answer

“The younger as sisters, with all purity” tells Timothy to treat younger women like his own sisters, with clean motives and behavior. When correction is needed, it should be done privately and respectfully, without flirting, suggestive talk, or anything that could stir up wrong desires. Purity here covers looks, words, and actions. It reminds all who serve in the church that dealings with the opposite sex must be guarded, honorable, and free from hidden motives.

Question 6

Why is purity especially stressed with younger women here?

Accepted Answer

Purity is stressed with younger women because of the natural temptations that can arise between men and women. Even someone serious about serving God, like Timothy, needed this warning, so no one is above it. When correcting or working closely with younger women, it is easy for feelings, glances, or words to cross a line. By calling Timothy to treat them as sisters and to act with “all purity,” Paul protects both Timothy and the women from sin and from suspicion.

Question 7

How does this passage guide the way correction should be done in church?

Accepted Answer

This passage shows that correction in the church should feel like a family dealing with problems, not like a judge attacking criminals. Older men are to be approached like fathers, older women like mothers, younger men like brothers, and younger women like sisters. The tone is gentle, respectful, and loving, while still honest about sin. It calls for careful speech, patient appeal, and especially pure conduct toward younger women, so that the church remains both truthful and clean.

Question 8

How can I apply treating others as fathers, mothers, brothers, and sisters today?

Accepted Answer

You can apply this by changing how you see people in your church. Instead of thinking of them as “those people,” see older men and women as spiritual parents, and those around your age as brothers and sisters. When you need to challenge someone, remember how you would want your own family to speak to you: not ignoring wrong, but speaking kindly, without harsh words or pride. This attitude grows patience, respect, and care in the whole church family.

1 Timothy 5:1

Rebuke not an elder, but intreat him as a father; and the younger men as brethren;

Reproof and Respect

Cross References

1 Timothy 5:1

Rebuke not an elder, but intreat him as a father; and the younger men as brethren;

Share Options

All Verses

Verse + Context

Current Verse

Reproof and Respect

Cross References