Question 1

Why was God displeased with David numbering the people?

Accepted Answer

God was displeased because David’s act of numbering the people came from pride and self-reliance, not from trust in God. David wanted to know the size of his army, which showed he was leaning on numbers and human strength. The passage shows that God sees the heart behind our actions. Counting the people was not just about gathering information, it exposed a proud spirit. When God “smote Israel,” it showed that even hidden motives matter, especially in leaders, and that God will correct his people when they wander into pride.

Question 2

What does David mean when he says, "I have sinned greatly"?

Accepted Answer

When David says, “I have sinned greatly,” he is not making excuses or softening what he did. He fully owns his guilt. He admits that commanding the counting of Israel was not a small mistake but a serious sin. He also adds that he has done “very foolishly,” showing he sees his pride as both wicked and senseless. His prayer, asking God to “do away the iniquity” of his servant, shows he wants more than relief from pain. He wants the guilt of his sin removed and his heart humbled.

Question 3

Why did God give David a choice of three punishments?

Accepted Answer

God gave David a choice between famine, defeat by enemies, or pestilence to deepen David’s humility and make him feel the weight of his sin. Having to choose put David “in a great strait,” pressed on every side by the horror of each option. This choice made him think seriously about God’s hand and man’s hand. It also showed that the judgment was not random, but measured and controlled by God. In the end, the choice David makes reveals where his trust still lies, even under discipline.

Question 4

What does it mean to "fall into the hand of the LORD" in this passage?

Accepted Answer

To “fall into the hand of the LORD” here means to submit to God’s direct discipline rather than suffer at the hands of human enemies. David believes that even when God is angry, his mercies are very great. Human enemies can be harsh and cruel, but God’s judgments are just and tempered with compassion. David would rather be corrected by God, who knows his heart and can say, “It is enough,” than be chased and destroyed by men. This shows a deep trust in God’s character, even while being punished.

Question 5

Who is Gad and what is his role in this story?

Accepted Answer

Gad is called David’s seer, which means he is a prophet who brings God’s word to the king. In this story, God speaks to Gad and sends him to David with a message of judgment and a hard choice. Gad does not speak his own ideas, he simply says, “Thus saith the LORD,” and lays out the three options. He also waits for David’s answer to bring it back to God. Gad’s role shows how God uses his messengers to guide, warn, and correct even the highest leaders.

Question 6

What are the three punishments offered to David, and how are they different?

Accepted Answer

The three punishments are: three years of famine, three months of being destroyed before enemies with their sword overtaking Israel, or three days of the sword of the LORD, a pestilence in the land with the angel of the LORD destroying across Israel. Famine would bring long, grinding suffering. Defeat by enemies would mean shame, fear, and human cruelty. The three days of pestilence would be very sharp and deadly, but shorter and clearly from God’s own hand. Each option shows a different way God can use created things to correct his people.

Question 7

What does this passage teach about God’s mercy in the middle of judgment?

Accepted Answer

This passage shows that even when God is displeased and sends judgment, his mercy is still real. David dares to say, “Very great are his mercies,” even as punishment is coming. God lets David choose, which already shows patience. Later in the wider story, God stops the angel and says, “It is enough,” proving that his anger has a limit and his compassion moves him to hold back. The scene reminds us that God’s discipline is not to destroy his people, but to humble them, turn them from pride, and restore them.

Question 8

How can David’s response help believers today when they have sinned?

Accepted Answer

David gives a pattern for how to respond when we sin. He calls his sin what it is, saying, “I have sinned greatly” and “I have done very foolishly,” without blaming others. He prays that God would take away his iniquity, showing concern for forgiveness, not just for escaping pain. When faced with discipline, he does not argue with God’s right to punish, but casts himself on God’s mercy, choosing to fall into God’s hand. This teaches us to confess plainly, accept God’s correction, and keep trusting his mercy.

1 Chronicles 21:7

And God was displeased with this thing; therefore he smote Israel.

Judgment for David’s Sin

Cross References

1 Chronicles 21:7

And God was displeased with this thing; therefore he smote Israel.

Share Options

All Verses

Verse + Context

Current Verse

Judgment for David’s Sin

Cross References